• Investing
  • Tech News
  • Stock
  • World News
Grand Expo Event
Editor's PickInvesting

Rutherford v. United States Brief: Defending the First Step Act

by August 15, 2025
August 15, 2025

Alexander Xenos

courtroom

The First Step Act of 2018 has been hailed as the most significant criminal justice reform bill in a generation. The overwhelmingly bipartisan legislation addressed disparities that plagued the federal criminal justice system and damaged its public legitimacy. Among other things, it eliminated the harsh “stacking” of mandatory minimums under 18 U.S.C. § 924(c). It also amended 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c), known as the compassionate release provision. 

Under that provision, a district court can reduce a defendant’s sentence if it determines that “extraordinary and compelling reasons warrant such a reduction.” Congress emphasized that the law would confer upon judges broad discretion to determine case-by-case whether circumstances warrant compassionate release.

Now, the Supreme Court is considering whether district courts can treat sentencing disparities created by the First Step Act’s changes as “extraordinary and compelling reasons” for sentence reductions. 

Cato, Right on Crime, and the Rutherford Institute filed a brief arguing that the plain text of the statute, its purpose, and the long-standing recognition of judicial discretion in sentencing all support allowing consideration of such disparities. A court can consider the fact that a defendant sentenced before the First Step Act would have received a significantly lower sentence today.

The First Step Act addressed widespread bipartisan concerns over excessively harsh and arbitrary sentences, particularly those involving mandatory minimums and stacked charges. Compassionate release was expanded precisely so that judges could address such injustices. Limiting judicial discretion to consider these sentencing disparities would not only frustrate congressional intent but also result in unnecessary and costly continued incarceration.

The Supreme Court should give effect to the ordinary meaning of the text and apply longstanding constitutional doctrine rather than re-entrench the injustices the First Step Act sought to remedy.

previous post
You Can’t Yell “Chicken Jockey” in a Crowded Theater (Except When You Can)

You may also like

Friday Feature: Braveheart Christian Academy

August 15, 2025

Jennings v. Smith Brief: Defending Alabamians from Illegal...

August 15, 2025

Did Oregon’s Drug Decriminalization Increase Crime or Overdoses?...

August 15, 2025

Please Stop Calling them “Reciprocal” Tariffs

August 14, 2025

Energy Department Not Interested In Government Transparency

August 14, 2025

A Bet on X, a Bottle of Scotch,...

August 14, 2025

ICE Could Prevent Some of the Coming Corruption,...

August 14, 2025

Election Policy Roundup

August 14, 2025

Anti-Profiling Court Order Cuts LA ICE Arrests by...

August 14, 2025

Freedom of Silence? England Investigating a Woman for...

August 14, 2025

    Fill Out & Get More Relevant News


    Stay ahead of the market and unlock exclusive trading insights & timely news. We value your privacy - your information is secure, and you can unsubscribe anytime. Gain an edge with hand-picked trading opportunities, stay informed with market-moving updates, and learn from expert tips & strategies.

    Recent Posts

    • Rutherford v. United States Brief: Defending the First Step Act

      August 15, 2025
    • Friday Feature: Braveheart Christian Academy

      August 15, 2025
    • Jennings v. Smith Brief: Defending Alabamians from Illegal Police Demands for ID

      August 15, 2025
    • Did Oregon’s Drug Decriminalization Increase Crime or Overdoses? —Separating Short-term Spikes from Long-term Trends

      August 15, 2025
    • Please Stop Calling them “Reciprocal” Tariffs

      August 14, 2025
    • Energy Department Not Interested In Government Transparency

      August 14, 2025
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 grandexpoevent.com | All Rights Reserved

    Grand Expo Event
    • Investing
    • Tech News
    • Stock
    • World News